SITE RATING: 6/10
SITE
REVIEW: My first
impression of this 1973 recording of Messiah
is how very 'British' the performance is. Sir
David Willcocks conducts each number with very
deliberate, stately tempos, as if he were
performing for the Queen Mum and afraid of
offending. This is certainly one of the more
idiosyncratic performances which I own, with
each solo and chorus taking a declamatory
stance, exactly as if a troupe of
Victorian-era head butlers were singing it.
The soloists are all very proper and a bit
stand-offish, and the Choir at King's College,
Cambridge comprised entirely of boys and men,
as well as The Academy of St
Martin-in-the-Fields are very good. But it's
all sung as if being conducted by a metronome;
I just can't shake the feeling while I'm
listening to this that this Messiah runs a
little too much like an atomic clock; exact,
precise, but with an internal temperature that
runs cold instead of hot. Worth hearing for
the astonishing differences in mood and
ambiance, compared to other, more fiery
performances. ~ BDW
|