SITE RATING: 7/10
SITE REVIEW:
Although the packaging on this double-DVD-R set is threadbare
(the enclosed booklet looks like it was printed on an old ink jet
printer) the performance it chronicles is warm, inviting, and a credit
to all involved. I purchased this through the Peterborough
Singers website, although since then, I have not been able to
find the purchasing link again, so I'm not sure if it is still
available. Despite my misgivings about the packaging, I was
greatly charmed by the performance. Professionally filmed at the
George Street United Church, using
multiple camera angles, and with a lush aural ambiance provided by the
cathedral's acoustics, I was immediately impressed by the warm
burnished sound, and the adeptness of both the organist, and each of
the soloists in turn. Organist Ian Sadler is world-class, and is
helped by what appears to be his ten-year-old son, who sits beside him
throughout the evening. Mr. Sadler's playing is deeply
sympathetic and vigorous, and he masters the instrument with great
skill. Besides organ, there is also some limited trumpet and percussion
present, but despite the limited instrumental forces, the sound is rich
and detailed. The soloists are also equally fine, with nary a
weak link to be found - tenor Adam Bishop sings with a youthful
force and he possesses a wonderful vocal color; Mezzo-soprano Jennifer
Ens Modolo is passionate and intense, singing with real feeling; Father
Paul Massel brings his Broadway-caliber baritone to his role,
masterfully performing his arias with deep conviction, and soprano
Sally Dibblee has a bright, natural bell-tone and pleasing demeanor.
Honestly, it's one of the best solo lineups I've found on DVD,
and well worth discovering. The Peterborough Singers, based in
Ontario, Canada, are similarly fine - but are perhaps the weak point
here, with most of the blame resting on director Syd Birrell's rather
safe and staid direction - much more dynamic expression could have been
used, bringing more drama to the choral sections, which are otherwise
well sung. That said, the beautiful acoustics, vibrant organ
playing, and marvelous soloists make this DVD one to seek out.
|
