SITE RATING: 1/10
SITE
REVIEW: According to
his own press release, Jeff Tincher spent
seven years
of his life creating this completely
computer-driven recreation of the complete
Handel's Messiah.
Instruments, voices, tempos, were all
artificially recreated via computer, and the
package is only available as a digital
download. The result is curious,
certainly, but a few short seconds of
listening is all that's needed to discern the
whole. Such artificial production
produces mechanical, soulless results, and the
perhaps unintended outcome of Tincher's seven
years of work is a reverse testimonial to the
worth of a human soul. The sound is hard
and shrill, the instrumentation is mushy and
heavily synthesized, and the overall effect is
completely lifeless. There's no
suprising changes in dynamic, or meaning
afforded the text, there's no musicianship, or
fine feeling, or inspiration, or art.
All his years of work to create this
work is immediately undone by listening to ANY
human-made recording, which will be infinitely
warmer and more accessible than this. If
Handel truly wrote this work in twenty-four
days, and a living, breathing peformance of Messiah
can be put together in a similar time-frame,
all that can be said of Jeff Tincher's seven
years creating is that it was time well and
truly wasted. For the curious only.
|