SITE RATING: 7/10
SITE REVIEW:
This
rare release by Orchestra Seattle and Seattle Chamber Singers,
conducted by George Shangrow, is one of the few truly complete
recordings of Messiah, and
also one of the few of the last three decades which completely eschews
the baroque music resurgence of the 1980s, instead hearkening back to
the large, slow Messiahs of
the 1950s and before. Even more surprising is that it's a good
recording; most locally-released albums such as this boast average
ensemble work and soloists, and while the soloists here aren't
world-class by any means, they're better than I expected.
Conductor George Shangrow allows ornamentation with both soloists
and orchestra, which can be distracting (and, in the instance of tenor
Stephen Wall, occasionally out of his reach), but when taking Messiah at such largo
tempos, ornamentation helps fill in the long spaces - it's entirely
justifiable, if not to my tastes. The Orchestra Seattle and
Seattle Chamber Singers are both very fine, with strongly defined
playing and singing, and well-separated in the recording.
Actually, when a performance is this slow and grand, I would
prefer a warmer, more "romantic" ambiance, and this one is very dry -
it allows for great clarity and separation, but robs the recording of
some of the warm, recorded beauty which the older recordings had, and
which benefited them. Of the other soloists, alto Emily Lunde has
a pleasing tone, but a wide vibrato which I dislike; bass Brian Box is
good, lacking only a truly vibrant tone in his arias, while soprano
Catherine Haight is my favorite here, with a clear, bright tone
sparkling with youth and joy. Overall, a pleasantly surprising Messiah, with excellent orchestral and choral work, diffident soloists, and a grand, slow tradition recreated for modern audiences.
|