SITE RATING: 8/10
SITE
REVIEW: Another
attempt to recreate the original "Dublin"
premiere performance of 1742, this bright new
recording by Hans-Christoff Rademann and the
Gaechinger Cantorey embraces Baroque
performance techniques, but doesn't eschew
warmth and accessibility in the process.
Recorded in the Margarethenkirche Gotha,
September 2019, the recording possesses a
natural ambience in recorded sound, and the
playing and singing are precise and
controlled. Tenor Benedikt Kristjansson
is very good - a natural, unforced timbre
gives his arias an unstudied, but pleasing
sound, with only the hint of vibrato, his tone
is straight, but full of expression.
Baritone Tobias Berndt has more of a natural
vibrato, but again, is unforced, and his warm
timbre is very pleasing. The Gaechinger
Cantorey are quite spectacular - with
wonderful clear tones, marvelous unity, and
good diction, containing just a hint of their
German origin. Counter-tenor Benno
Schachtner is fine, with a creamy tone, but
giving some odd accents to his readings, and
being the most 'mannered' of the soloists, his
readings are more studied, and less purely
natural - I found him the weakest of the four
soloists - calling attention to himself with
distracting ornamentation. Soprano
Dorothee Fields has a rich tone and fruity
vibrato which I enjoyed - she has a cheerful
timbre which brings welcome lightness to her
arias. Tempos are generally moderate,
and occasionally workmanlike, but the
recording has several moments of undeniable
beauty - and rates as one of the more
accomplished recordings in recent
memory. Recommended.
|