SITE RATING: 2/10
SITE
REVIEW: Sir John
Pritchard's tenure with the London
Philharmonic dates from 1961-1966, and this
recording, which I'm guessing comes from that
era, sounds very much of its time, with
everything overblown, both in performance and
sonically. The London Philharmonic
Chorus sounds as if they're singing their very
lungs out, and the Orchestra plays with deep,
melodramatic swells in the grand, romantic
style, but more so - this is a Messiah played
and sung with great heaving, panting effort.
The soloists are hit-and-miss; tenor
Richard Lewis and soprano Heather Harper have
lovely tones, but tend to swoop from note to
note, bass John Holmes is very throaty and
hollow-toned, and alto Norma Procter sings
with great feeling, and similarly great
Wagnerian weight. The Philarmonic
Orchestra and Chorus are sloppy here, with
ragged entrances and cut-offs, and the
recorded sound is thick with echo - the choir
especially sounds disunified, with the tenors
punching out of the sound far more than the
other parts. With a bare minimum of
tracks present, and the very old, shabby sound
afforded this performance, I wouldn't
recommend this disc over other, better
selections.
|