RECORDINGS |
|
LABEL: |
CLASSICAL
MOMENTS |
CATALOG
NUMBER: |
UNKNOWN |
UPC
NUMBER: |
N/A |
NUMBER OF DISCS: |
2 |
RUNNING TIME: |
1:09:26,
43:50 |
DATE
RECORDED: |
1959 |
RELEASE
DATE: |
OCTOBER
20, 2010 |
CONDUCTOR: |
FRANCESCO
MOLINARI-PRADELLI |
ORCHESTRA: |
RAI
SYMPHONY ORCHESTRA OF MILAN |
CHOIR: |
UNKNOWN |
SOPRANO: |
ANNA
MOFFO |
MEZZO-SOPRANO: |
GIOVANNA
FLORONI |
TENOR: |
HERBERT
HANDT |
BASS: |
IVO
VINCO |
|
|
|
DISC ONE
1. Messiah: Part I, The Annunciation
& Part IIa, The Passion 1:09:26
|
DISC TWO
1. Messiah: Part IIb, The
Passion & Part III, The Aftermath
43:50
|
|
SITE RATING: 3/10
SITE
REVIEW: Easily one of
the worst-sounding Messiahs to ever be
commercially released, this mp3-only album, a
1959 recording put out by the "Classical
Moments" label, sounds as if it was taken from
an old radio broadcast - with strident,
compressed sound, loads of hiss and crackle,
omnipresent audience noise (it's so loud that
it seems as if the audience has been mic'ed
along with the performers), and topped off by
a ham-fisted performance that made me grind my
teeth. The recording is notable in being
one of the very few Italian-language Messiah's
ever captured, and is here presented by the
RAI Symphony Orchestra of Milan, under the
baton of Francesco Molinari Pradelli
(1911-1996), a prominent Italian opera
conductor. Pradelli's greatest claim to
fame is his 1966 recording of Puccini's Turandot with Birgit
Nillson and Franco Corelli, and here, he
conducts the RAI with all the might and force
of grand opera, giving Messiah a
thunderous weight that you simply won't find
in modern recordings. This occasionally
gives unusual color to certain moments, as in
the unexpected subito piano found at the
close of "And The Glory Of The Lord"; but for
the most part, Pradelli seems content to push
the pedal all the way to the floor throughout,
with the soloists, all drawn from the operatic
sphere, giving accomplished, full-throated
readings, and the unnamed choir powering their
ways through the choruses as if they
were attempting to drill a hole through a
brick wall by the sheer force of their sound.
The recording is unfortunately hampered by the
two discs being unsequenced, each half having
only one long track to choose from. That
major inconvenience, along with the extremely
poor recorded sound, make this a release I can
recommend only to ardent collectors.
|
|