SITE RATING: 1/10
SITE REVIEW:
Lumbering, mechanical, and rote are just a few of the
adjectives that spring to mind in listening to this 1974 recording made
by the combined musical departments of the University of
Missouri-Columbia, under the baton of Ira C. Powell. With tempos that
wouldn't be out of place during the last ice age, the glacial speed
taken by Powell accounts for the reason why, despite having the luxury
of a double-LP set, nearly half of Handel's oratorio needed to be cut.
Add to that the unrestrained sawing of the University Symphony
Orchestra and out of tune playing throughout, and you'd be hard-pressed
to find a more teeth-grinding listening experience. Tenor Robert
Bohon is both shrill and unaccomplished, with wide-open vowels that
bespeaks more of a Broadway "belt" than classical tendencies. The
Missouri-Columbia University Chorus of 1974 is singularly poor,
sledge-hammering the choruses mercilessly, bludgeoning everything to a
bloody pulp. Alto Tacey Brewer has a simple, pleasant tone, while
untrained, is pleasant, while soprano Cindy Purdy is similarly simple
and unadorned, with a pure, white tone that is undercut only by the
wayward tone of the orchestra. Bass Martin Loring is perhaps the
brightest star here, injecting much-needed passion into his arias, but
even he sounds far too young to be tackling this role. There's
nothing here worth seeking out for the curious, unless you have an
affinity for "bad" Messiahs.
|