SITE RATING:
9/10
SITE REVIEW:
This 1995 Der Messias
under the baton of Enoch zu Guttenberg is hard to find outside of
Germany (and is rare even there), but is a fine, strongly
Teutonic-flavored addition to the canon of Mozart-arranged Messiah’s available.
Generally speaking, this is a richer, darker performance of Der Messias than other’s
I’ve heard, with Mozart’s distinctive flourishes being
accentuated to good effect, and the singers hearkening from operatic
backgrounds. Guttenberg’s tempos are moderately slow, and
the modern instrumentation gives everything a deeper, smoother
sound. In fact, this sounds a great deal like a throwback to the
grander performances of the 1950s, only with far greater finesse and
feeling, and vastly improved sonic clarity. Tenor Ludwig Van
Gijsegem is marvelous, with a warm operatic tone and deep connection to
the material, while bass Deitrich Henshel is truly heroic - bringing an
impressive tonal color to his arias. Alto Ingeborg Danz is
similarly adorned with a dark, creamy tone, and connects fully with her
performance. Mezzo soprano Katalin Halmai is very good, sounding
only a bit forced in her upper registers, while soprano Malin Hartelius
has a glorious sound, but strikes her arias with a strangely
declamatory stance, giving arias like “I know that my Redeemer
liveth” a confrontational feel that is quite different from other
performances I’ve heard. The Mitteldeuschen Rundfunks Choir
and Philharmonic are both tremendous here, with great swells of pathos
and thunderous choruses proficiently alternating. What a shame
that this magnificent performance has fallen out of print - it’s
one of the most pleasing, stirring Der
Messias I’ve ever heard - and deserves to be appreciated
on a worldwide stage.
|