SITE RATING: 4/10
SITE
REVIEW: I imagine
that if you're a committed flautist, or love
the sound of flute music, then this solo
project by Andy Findon will be right up your
alley. But to me, what begins as a
curiosity quickly spirals into an annoyance,
and then torture. The conceit is
simple - Mr. Findon has arranged nineteen
movements of Messiah for chamber flutes, and
only flutes, no other instrumentation
or vocals are included. And, not
willing to enlist any other flautists for
the project, he has painstakingly
multi-tracked all of the parts
himself. While this kind of vanity
project can be interesting in the hands of a
talented polyinstrumentalist, Andy
Findon's talents are sturdily capable, and
doesn't rise to the level of world-class
expertise needed to really bring these
selections to life. There's little in
the way of dynamic change from piece to
piece, and after a few short minutes, the
similar timbres, square interpretations, and
Findon's own set talents become monotonous
in the extreme. That's not to
completely disparage the effort - I think
that the arrangements themselves are quite
canny for a chamber piece, and would like to
hear it re-recorded with a small mixed group
of instruments, but this effort is mainly
hamstrung by the grating sameness of it all.
|