SITE RATING: 8/10
SITE
REVIEW: The sole Messiah to
be released in 2015, this impressive set by
director Peter Dijkstra, featuring the B'Rock
Belgian Baroque Orchestra Ghent and Chor des
Bayerischen Rundfunks has several thrilling
moments, and even without competition, it
would rate as perhaps the best Messiah
of the year. Warmly recorded and
performed, the B'Rock Belgian Baroque manages
to bring real depth of sound to their
instruments, and Dijkstra clearly enjoys
searching for tender moments to bring to fore,
eschewing the cold, clean "white" sound of
most modern baroque ensembles, and infusing
them with a touch of welcome 20th Century
grandeur. The Chor des Bayerischen also
brings a soupçon more warmth and richness to
their tone than has been typical of other
modern interpretations. Among the
soloists, Julia Doyle exemplifies the
sweetness of Dijkstra's reading, singing with
great emotional depth and a pure, liquid
tone. Tenor Steve Davislim is a fine,
heroic presence, a touch brighter in tone and
interpretation than Doyle, but never shrill or
piercing. Countertenor Lawerence Zazzo
is fine, although I confess I would have
preferred an alto in the role - simply due to
the feeling that a warm alto tone would have
better fitted the overall fabric of the
performance. Bass/Baritone Neal Davies
is the weak link here - his tone is the most
aggressive, and his melismas can have a
strident, punching quality that pops out of
the speakers in an unpleasant way.
Dijkstra's tempos are noticeably subdued and
easier than what has become the norm - but
again, this fits the pleasant tenor this
recording has - tonal colors are allowed to
breathe in spacious moments, and in what
appears to be a continuing trend among
musicologists, the pendulum is swinging back
to larger, more expansive readings. I
must say I enjoy it - this is a more
contemplative, but equally memorable, Messiah,
and worth hearing.
|